Falaah Falaah AI

Deficiencies

A failed, signed-off control test becomes a deficiency. Rate its severity, pick a compensating control or a retest, and close it only when the fix is proven.

A deficiency records that a control did not work. Muin creates one when a control test is signed off with a failed or partial result. You find them on the Deficiencies tab of the framework (/compliance/frameworks/:id?tab=deficiencies).

How a deficiency is created

When the last sign-off step approves a test whose result is not a pass, Muin opens one deficiency:

  • Status Open
  • Severity Deficiency
  • Description taken from the test’s conclusion
  • A link back to the test (the sign-off panel shows View deficiency)

Nobody types a deficiency in by hand, so every one traces back to signed-off work.

Severity

Severity Meaning
Deficiency The control did not work as designed or did not operate, but the gap is unlikely to matter on its own.
Significant deficiency Less severe than a material weakness, yet important enough to bring to the attention of those overseeing financial reporting.
Material weakness A reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented or caught in time.

The person who rates it decides the severity. A material weakness needs a remediation owner and a due date before it can be saved.

Remediation: compensating control or retest

Pick exactly one:

  • Compensating control: another control in the same framework covers the gap.
  • Retest: Muin creates a draft retest of the same control. It shows in the test plan as “Retest after a failed test”.

Picking one moves the deficiency from Open to Remediating.

Closing

Close is allowed only once the fix is proven:

  • the retest was signed off with a pass, or
  • the compensating control has a signed-off passing test whose period ends on or after the day the deficiency was raised.

If neither is true, Muin refuses the close and names what is missing. A closed deficiency is read-only and leaves the open count.

Quarterly test plan

On the Tests tab, the Planned view lists what is due each quarter: controls due by their frequency, and retests after a failed test. Start test opens a new draft; Open test goes to one already started.