Deficiencies
A failed, signed-off control test becomes a deficiency. Rate its severity, pick a compensating control or a retest, and close it only when the fix is proven.
A deficiency records that a control did not work. Muin creates one when a control test is signed off with a failed or partial result. You find them on the Deficiencies tab of the framework (/compliance/frameworks/:id?tab=deficiencies).
How a deficiency is created
When the last sign-off step approves a test whose result is not a pass, Muin opens one deficiency:
- Status Open
- Severity Deficiency
- Description taken from the test’s conclusion
- A link back to the test (the sign-off panel shows View deficiency)
Nobody types a deficiency in by hand, so every one traces back to signed-off work.
Severity
| Severity | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Deficiency | The control did not work as designed or did not operate, but the gap is unlikely to matter on its own. |
| Significant deficiency | Less severe than a material weakness, yet important enough to bring to the attention of those overseeing financial reporting. |
| Material weakness | A reasonable possibility that a material misstatement would not be prevented or caught in time. |
The person who rates it decides the severity. A material weakness needs a remediation owner and a due date before it can be saved.
Remediation: compensating control or retest
Pick exactly one:
- Compensating control: another control in the same framework covers the gap.
- Retest: Muin creates a draft retest of the same control. It shows in the test plan as “Retest after a failed test”.
Picking one moves the deficiency from Open to Remediating.
Closing
Close is allowed only once the fix is proven:
- the retest was signed off with a pass, or
- the compensating control has a signed-off passing test whose period ends on or after the day the deficiency was raised.
If neither is true, Muin refuses the close and names what is missing. A closed deficiency is read-only and leaves the open count.
Quarterly test plan
On the Tests tab, the Planned view lists what is due each quarter: controls due by their frequency, and retests after a failed test. Start test opens a new draft; Open test goes to one already started.